Search

Gainesville, Florida: A General's Name and a 'Gain' Story

General Edmund Pendleton Gaines gave Gainesville, Florida, its name. He commanded U.S. Army troops in Florida during the Second Seminole War. The town was created in 1853, when Alachua County moved its seat from Newnansville to a site on the planned Florida Railroad. Henry Gannett's 1905 book of American place names gives the same namesake.

Detail of an 1890 U.S. Geological Survey map with the word GAINESVILLE in capital letters beside a dense grid of streets and small black squares for buildings, brown contour lines around it, and railroad lines marked Peninsular and Fla. crossing the town, with a sink and a place called Millard to the southwest.
Gainesville and its railroads on the U.S. Geological Survey's Arredondo sheet, 1890. U.S. Geological Survey, Arredondo sheet (1:62,500), 1890. Public domain. Cropped for display.

A town built for a courthouse

Gainesville, Florida, began in 1853 as a new county seat beside a railroad that hadn’t been built yet, and it took the name of General Edmund P. Gaines. Gaines had commanded U.S. Army troops in Florida during the Second Seminole War, and that’s the namesake you’ll find on the state’s historical marker at City Hall, in the city’s own records and in a federal book of place names from 1905.

The town exists because of the Florida Railroad. Alachua County’s history explains that the route, which the City of Alachua says ran from Fernandina to Cedar Key, cut diagonally across the county and bypassed the county seat at Newnansville, off in the northwest. So at a meeting at Boulware Springs on September 6, 1853, the county decided to move its seat near the tracks and create a new town. The Gainesville Police Department’s history says the place “received its name in September, 1853, when the County Commission provided a site for a new town.”

The general on the marker

Edmund Pendleton Gaines is the man the official sources agree on. The state marker, put up in 1969, says Gainesville “takes its name from General Edmund Gaines, captor of Aaron Burr and commander of U.S. Army troops in Florida during the Second Seminole War.” The police history uses almost the same words and adds his middle name.

That isn’t just a modern plaque talking. In 1905 Henry Gannett’s guide for the U.S. Geological Survey put Gainesville, Florida, into a national list of place names in a single line that lumps it with three other Gainesvilles, in Georgia, New York and Texas, all “named for Gen. E. P. Gaines.” That’s a lot of towns for one officer.

Who actually suggested the name at that 1853 meeting is another matter. The county’s history passes along a tradition that some Seminole War veterans in the crowd proposed it in honor of the general they’d served under, but it labels that part a legend. So you’ve got a firm answer on the who, and only a story on the how.

A hotly contested vote, and the “gain”

Moving a courthouse wasn’t a quiet affair. In 1883 C. H. Webber, writing The Eden of the South, a guide to Alachua County for tourists and would-be settlers, described how Newnansville had held on to the county seat:

“Newnansville was formerly the county seat of Alachua, and held it with commendable pride until the wisdom of the people, in 1854, after a hotly contested election, removed it to the younger but more central settlement at Gainesville.”

That fight also left a story behind. The City of Alachua, which grew up near old Newnansville, tells it this way: the county commission’s vote at first went Newnansville’s way, until a landowner near the rail line talked several people into changing their minds. In a line about the origin of Gainesville’s name, the city adds that one story says the town “owes its importance to this ‘gain’ in votes.”

The version that ties the name itself to the vote comes from 1936. On November 9 of that year Dr. J. Dawkins Tench, whose family had moved to Gainesville in 1879, gave a Works Progress Administration interviewer his account of the county’s past. He said the usual explanation was wrong, that the town wasn’t named for General Gaines at all, and that it was named after its site won the county-seat election over Newnansville by a small margin. The transcript is in the state archives’ Florida Memory collection.

It’s a good story, and it fits the close vote Webber described. But Tench was recalling something that happened more than 80 years earlier, decades before his family arrived, and his account is a memory, not a record from 1853. Gannett’s book, the marker and the city all say Gaines. That’s why this page treats the general as the documented origin and the “gain” as a tradition worth knowing about.

Not a renamed Newnansville

One thing the “gain” story can make confusing: Gainesville didn’t replace Newnansville the way a new name replaces an old one. They were two different places. The City of Alachua says Newnansville, once the county seat, slowly declined after the railroad passed it by, and after another rail line bypassed it in 1884 its people moved to a new town that became Alachua.

Gainesville, meanwhile, grew into exactly what it was built to be. The county counts about 232 residents in 1860, and the marker says it was incorporated as a city in 1869 and was Alachua County’s fourth seat of government. When Gainesville was picked for the University of Florida in 1905, the courthouse town on the railroad had carried the general’s name for half a century. That same year, Gannett’s book put it in print.

Quick answers

Who was Gainesville, Florida, named after?

General Edmund Pendleton Gaines, who commanded U.S. Army troops in Florida during the Second Seminole War. The state’s 1969 marker, the city’s police history and Gannett’s 1905 place-name book all say so.

Was Gainesville named for “gaining” the county seat?

That’s a later tradition, not the documented answer. Dr. J. Dawkins Tench told a WPA interviewer in 1936 that the town was named for winning the county-seat election, and the City of Alachua mentions the “gain” in votes as “one story,” but the older and official sources name General Gaines.

Was Gainesville ever called Newnansville?

No. Newnansville was a separate town and the earlier county seat. The seat moved from there to the new town of Gainesville after a hotly contested election in 1854.

When was Gainesville, Florida, founded?

The county decided to create the town on September 6, 1853. It became the county seat in 1854 and was incorporated as a city in 1869.

Key dates

  1. 1853September 6: a meeting at Boulware Springs decides to move the Alachua County seat near the planned railroad and create the new town of Gainesville.
  2. 1854After a hotly contested election, the county seat moves from Newnansville to Gainesville.
  3. 1860Gainesville has about 232 residents, according to Alachua County's history.
  4. 1869Gainesville is incorporated as a city.
  5. 1905Henry Gannett's federal place-name book lists Gainesville, Florida, as named for Gen. E. P. Gaines.
  6. 1936November 9: Dr. J. Dawkins Tench tells a WPA interviewer the town was named for winning the county-seat election, not for Gaines.
A downtown street in Gainesville in late-afternoon light, with two- and three-story brick buildings, trees turning red and yellow along the sidewalk, parked cars at the curb and a clear blue sky.
Downtown Gainesville, November 2021. Photo: reedberkowitz, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

Getting there

Open Gainesville in Google Maps

Opens in a new tab. The pin is the center of Gainesville in the USGS place-name record.

The closest airports, Amtrak stations and intercity bus stops, measured in a straight line from the center of Gainesville.

Airports

Amtrak trains

Intercity buses

  • FlixBus Gainesville under 1 mi 0.7 km
  • Amtrak Chartered Vehicle Amtrak Connecting Service · Gainesville Amtrak Bus Stop 2 mi 2 km
  • Greyhound Gainesville Bus Stop 4 mi 7 km

Distances are as the crow flies, not by road. We don't list schedules or fares because they change; check with the airline, Amtrak or the bus company before you go. Official data (FAA commercial service airports (2025), FAA airport locations, Amtrak stations and Intercity Bus Atlas) from the FAA and the U.S. Bureau of Transportation Statistics, checked Nov 13, 2026.

Sponsored

Staying in Gainesville?

Compare hotels in Gainesville, Florida, on Expedia.

See hotels in Gainesville

We may earn a commission if you buy through this link. It never changes what we write. Read our affiliate disclosure

Historical Sources & References

Spot something wrong, or know more? Tell us here. You can also or use our contact page. Corrections are noted here with their date, never made silently.

More name stories

State of Florida

Florida: Named for Easter, and a Coast Full of Trees

Florida got its name in 1513 from Juan Ponce de León, who reached the coast in the Easter season, Pascua Florida, and liked the look of its green woods.

Documented
Marion County, FL

Ocala, Florida: A Timucua Name and the Big Hammock Question

Ocala, Florida, carries the name of a Timucua town Hernando de Soto heard so much about he dared not repeat it all, and sources disagree on what it means.

Disputed
Space center, FL

Kennedy Space Center: Named for JFK a Week After Dallas

Kennedy Space Center got its name a week after John F. Kennedy died, when Lyndon B. Johnson renamed NASA's Launch Operations Center for him.

Documented
Duval County, FL

Jacksonville, Florida: Before Jackson, It Was the Cow Ford

Before Jacksonville, Florida, had a name, the spot on the St. Johns River was the Cow Ford, where cattle crossed. In 1822 it was named for Andrew Jackson.

Documented
Mountain range, TN, NC

Great Smoky Mountains: Why They're Called "Smoky"

The Great Smoky Mountains are named for the blue haze that hangs over their ridges, and the National Park Service says the forest makes it.

Documented
St. Johns County, FL

St. Augustine, Florida: A Name Off the Calendar in 1565

The Spanish fleet that founded St. Augustine, Florida, reached the coast on August 28, 1565. On the Catholic calendar, that was St. Augustine's day.

Documented
FeaturedLeon County, FL

Tallahassee, Florida: A New Capital Named "Old Town"

In 1823, the men picking a site for Florida's capital rode past two Tallahassees, an old Indian town and a new one, and the capital took the name.

Documented
Lake County, FL

How Mount Dora, Florida, Got Its Name From Lake Dora

Before it was Mount Dora, this Florida town by Lake Dora was Royallieu or Royellou, depending on who spelled it, and nobody can say for sure who Dora was.

Disputed
Poster Master's illustrated pictorial map of Florida
SponsoredPoster · Poster Master

Florida pictorial map poster

An old illustrated map of Florida, sold as a poster by Poster Master.

We may earn a commission if you buy through this link.