How Surprise, Arizona Got Its Name, and Why It's Disputed
According to her daughter, Elizabeth Wusich Stoft, founder Flora Mae Statler once said she'd be surprised if the town ever amounted to much, and that's the story Surprise tells today. For years, though, historians believed Homer C. Ludden had founded the town and named it after his tiny hometown in Nebraska.

Flora Mae Statler once said she’d be surprised if her town ever amounted to much, her daughter recalled, and that’s the story behind Surprise, Arizona. It’s the version the city tells now, but for years the credit went to a different person, Homer C. Ludden, and to a village in Nebraska.
One square mile and one doubtful remark
The city’s tourism site, Explore Surprise, asks the question right on its “About” page: “What’s the story behind our name?” Its answer starts in 1938. “Our city was just one square mile of farmland back in 1938 when Flora Mae Statler founded it,” the page says. As for the name, it leans on one witness, Statler’s daughter, Elizabeth Wusich Stoft. According to her, “her mother once commented” that “she would be surprised if the town ever amounted to much.”
Keep in mind what kind of evidence that is. It’s a daughter’s memory of something her mother said, not a line written down in 1938. We haven’t seen a letter, a deed or a 1938 newspaper story with Statler’s words in it. When the Phoenix New Times retold the story in 2014, the quote had shifted slightly: Statler would be surprised if the town “ever amounted to anything.” Same idea, slightly different words.
The Ludden version
The other story is older, and the city itself helped retire it. In that 2014 article, reporter Ray Stern wrote that “historians had long believed Statler’s husband, Homer C. Ludden, founded the city and named it after his Nebraska hometown, a tiny village of fewer than 50 people.” Then, he wrote, “as city researchers found, Statler was the founder,” citing “a 2010 book put out by the city.” We weren’t able to read that book, or the state library’s records on Ludden, so we can’t tell you exactly what evidence the city’s researchers weighed.
Notice what the newer finding settles and what it doesn’t. It moves the credit for founding from Ludden to Statler. The naming story, though, still rests on the daughter’s account. If you want proof of who first wrote “Surprise” on paper, the published accounts cited here don’t give it.
The Nebraska town with the same name
There really is a Surprise in Nebraska, in Butler County, and it has its own naming story, much older than Arizona’s. Lilian Fitzpatrick’s Nebraska Place-Names, published by the University of Nebraska in 1925, explains it in one sentence:
“Surprise was so named by the settlers because they were surprised to find the land so much better than they expected it to be after their first tour through this part of the country.”
So the Nebraska village’s name came from a pleasant surprise. Arizona’s, if the daughter’s account is right, came from the opposite: a founder who didn’t expect much. Stern’s article doesn’t name Ludden’s hometown, and the only Surprise in Fitzpatrick’s index of Nebraska names is this one in Butler County.
A spot called Lizard, and a city past 100,000
The 1957 federal survey map shows how small the place still was nearly 20 years after 1938: a few blocks of streets and buildings beside the railroad and a highway, with the name Lizard printed beside the tracks just up the line. The same sheet marks “PHOENIX (P.O.) 20 MI.” down the road.
Surprise sits on the west side of the Phoenix metro area, and the New Times put its population at more than 100,000 by 2014. Whatever the true story, a town whose founder supposedly doubted it would amount to much had grown into a city of that size in Arizona.
Quick answers
How did Surprise, Arizona, get its name?
It isn’t settled in the sources cited here. The city’s tourism site says founder Flora Mae Statler once said she’d be surprised if the town ever amounted to much, according to her daughter; older accounts said Homer C. Ludden named it after his Nebraska hometown.
Who founded Surprise, Arizona?
Flora Mae Statler, according to the city’s tourism site and, the Phoenix New Times says, a 2010 book put out by the city. Historians had long credited Homer C. Ludden, who the Phoenix New Times says was Statler’s husband.
When was Surprise, Arizona, founded?
In 1938, says Explore Surprise, when the town was one square mile (2.6 km²) of farmland.
Is there a Surprise in Nebraska too?
Yes. Surprise, in Butler County, Nebraska, was named by settlers who were surprised to find the land better than they expected, according to a 1925 University of Nebraska study.
Key dates
- 1925A University of Nebraska study says settlers named Surprise, Nebraska, because the land was better than they expected.
- 1938Flora Mae Statler founds Surprise on one square mile of farmland, according to the city's tourism site.
- 1957A federal survey map shows Surprise as a few blocks of streets beside the railroad, with the name Lizard printed up the line.
- 2010A book put out by the city names Statler as the founder, according to the Phoenix New Times.

Getting there
Open Surprise in Google Maps
Opens in a new tab. The pin is the center of Surprise in the USGS place-name record.
The closest airports, Amtrak stations and intercity bus stops, measured in a straight line from the center of Surprise.
Airports
- Phoenix Sky Harbor International (PHX) 23 mi 37 km
- Mesa Gateway (IWA) 45 mi 72 km
Amtrak trains
- Maricopa station (MRC) 43 mi 69 km
Intercity buses
- FlixBus Glendale 59Th Ave / W. Hayward 10 mi 16 km
- Stagecoach Express Amtrak Connecting Service · North Phoenix Metro Center Transit Station 12 mi 20 km
- Greyhound Phoenix Glendale Bus Stop 14 mi 23 km
Distances are as the crow flies, not by road. We don't list schedules or fares because they change; check with the airline, Amtrak or the bus company before you go. Official data (FAA commercial service airports (2025), FAA airport locations, Amtrak stations and Intercity Bus Atlas) from the FAA and the U.S. Bureau of Transportation Statistics, checked Nov 13, 2026.
Sponsored
Staying in Surprise?
Compare hotels in Surprise, Arizona, on Expedia.
See hotels in SurpriseWe may earn a commission if you buy through this link. It never changes what we write. Read our affiliate disclosure
Historical Sources & References
- Explore Surprise, “About Surprise”. The founding by Flora Mae Statler in 1938 on one square mile of farmland, and her daughter Elizabeth Wusich Stoft’s account that Statler “would be surprised if the town ever amounted to much.”
- Ray Stern, “10 Best ‘Surprise’ Headlines From Surprise, Arizona,” Phoenix New Times (2014). The 2010 city book naming Statler as founder, the older belief that Homer C. Ludden founded the town and named it after his Nebraska hometown, Ludden as Statler’s husband, the “amounted to anything” wording and the population of more than 100,000.
- Lilian Linder Fitzpatrick, Nebraska Place-Names (1925), p. 30. The entry for Surprise in Butler County, Nebraska, named by settlers “surprised to find the land so much better than they expected.”
- GNIS feature 12009 (U.S. Geological Survey). Surprise’s populated-place entry in Maricopa County, with no history note on the name.
- U.S. Geological Survey, Calderwood Butte sheet (1:24,000), 1957. A 1957 quadrangle sheet that shows Surprise beside the railroad, the name Lizard up the line and “PHOENIX (P.O.) 20 MI.”
Spot something wrong, or know more? Tell us here. You can also email us or use our contact page. Corrections are noted here with their date, never made silently.








