Search

Cape May, NJ: Named for a Dutch Captain Called Mey

Cape May takes its name from the cape that Dutch captain Cornelius Jacobsen Mey named for himself. Lewis Townsend Stevens's 1897 county history says he christened it Cape Mey in 1623; the city's website gives 1621 on one page and 1611 to 1614 on another. The town itself was called Cape Island until 1869.

Detail of an 1888 U.S. Geological Survey map of the tip of New Jersey with Cape May City and West Cape May beside the ocean, Cape Island Creek and Cape Island Sound behind them, Poverty Beach, Sewell's Point and the Cape May and Sewell's Point railroad.
Cape May City and Cape Island Creek on the U.S. Geological Survey's Cape May sheet, 1888. U.S. Geological Survey, Cape May sheet (1:62,500), 1888. Public domain. Cropped for display.

Mey, not May

Cape May isn’t named for the month but for Cornelius Jacobsen Mey, a Dutch captain, and the city’s own website gives two different dates for his visit. On its “History of Cape May” page, the City of Cape May writes of a “sighting by Sir Henry Hudson in 1609, and exploration by Cornelius Jacobsen Mey in 1621.” On its “About Cape May” page, it says the city “was named for Dutch captain Cornelius Jacobsen Mey, who explored and chartered the area from 1611 to 1614.”

Both pages agree on the man, so you can take that part as settled. The year is the slippery bit, and an old county history adds a third one.

The captain who named the coast after himself

Lewis Townsend Stevens, who published The History of Cape May County in 1897, puts Mey’s naming on a voyage in 1623. Stevens says Mey sailed in the ship Blyde Broodschap, or Glad Tidings, reached Manhattan in May 1623 and was styled the first director of New Netherland. Then he went south:

“It was during this voyage in 1623, to Delaware Bay, that Captain Mey gave to the Cape his name, and christened it Cape Mey…” (Stevens, The History of Cape May County, p. 16)

Mey wasn’t shy with his own name. Stevens says he called the bay of New York “Port Mey” and the Delaware “New Port Mey,” named the northern cape of the Delaware Cape Mey and the southern one Cape Cornelius, and built Fort Nassau on Timber Creek. Only one of those names lasted, Stevens notes, with the “e” changed to an “a.”

The spelling wandered in other places too. The county and city were named “from the cape named for Cornelis Jacobse May, a navigator in the employ of the Dutch West Indian Company,” according to the Geological Survey’s 1905 roundup of name origins by Henry Gannett. Its entry for the cape itself calls him Cornelius Jacobson May.

Cape Island first

The town at the tip of the cape didn’t carry the cape’s name for a long time. The city’s history speaks of “this area now known as Cape Island,” home to the Kechemeche, a Lenni-Lenape people, and dates the start of the resort to 1766.

John P. Snyder’s 1969 study of New Jersey’s civil boundaries gives the legal steps. Cape Island became a borough, formed from Lower Township, on March 8, 1848. It became a city on March 10, 1851. Then, on March 9, 1869, Snyder records the change plainly: “Became Cape May city.” Stevens adds that the borough form didn’t suit the people there, which is why they got a city charter in 1851. The city says the railroad had reached Cape Island in 1863, and a fire swept through the resort in 1878.

The old name hung on after the switch. On the 1888 survey map at the top of this page, you’ll see “Cape May City” printed next to Cape Island Creek and Cape Island Sound.

Quick answers

Is Cape May named after the month of May?

No. It’s named for Cornelius Jacobsen Mey, a Dutch captain who gave the cape his own name, Cape Mey, according to Stevens’s 1897 county history and the City of Cape May.

What was Cape May called before?

Cape Island. It became a borough under that name in 1848 and a city in 1851, and the city of Cape Island became the city of Cape May on March 9, 1869.

Who was Cornelius Jacobsen Mey?

A Dutch sea captain. Stevens says he reached Manhattan in 1623 in the ship Blyde Broodschap and was styled the first director of New Netherland; Gannett says he worked for the “Dutch West Indian Company.”

Key dates

  1. 1609Henry Hudson sights the area, according to the City of Cape May.
  2. 1621The city's history page dates Cornelius Jacobsen Mey's exploration to this year; another city page says 1611 to 1614.
  3. 1623Stevens's county history says Mey reaches Manhattan in May and, on the same voyage, names the cape Cape Mey.
  4. 1766The city dates the start of Cape Island as a resort to this year.
  5. 1848March 8: the borough of Cape Island is formed from Lower Township.
  6. 1851March 10: Cape Island becomes a city.
  7. 1863The railroad reaches Cape Island.
  8. 1869March 9: the city of Cape Island becomes the city of Cape May.
  9. 1878A fire burns through the resort.
A two-story white clapboard house with a steep gray roof, dormer windows, carved trim along the gable, red shutters and a wraparound porch with white railings and an American flag, under a blue sky.
A house on Columbia Avenue, Cape May. Photo: Bmzuckerman, CC BY 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons (cropped).

Getting there

Open Cape May in Google Maps

Opens in a new tab. The pin is the center of Cape May in the USGS place-name record.

The closest airports, Amtrak stations and intercity bus stops, measured in a straight line from the center of Cape May.

Airports

Amtrak trains

Intercity buses

  • OurBus Cape May, NJ (Downtown - NW corner of Lyle Lane & Decatur St in front of Comfort Station across Rotary Park - approx address 308 Decatur St (transfer required at Galloway with hired car or rideshare)) under 1 mi 1 km
  • FlixBus Dover 7-Eleven 37 mi 60 km
  • Greyhound Atlantic City Pacific Ave 38 mi 61 km

Distances are as the crow flies, not by road. We don't list schedules or fares because they change; check with the airline, Amtrak or the bus company before you go. Official data (FAA commercial service airports (2025), FAA airport locations, Amtrak stations and Intercity Bus Atlas) from the FAA and the U.S. Bureau of Transportation Statistics, checked Nov 13, 2026.

Sponsored

Staying in Cape May?

Compare hotels in Cape May, New Jersey, on Expedia.

See hotels in Cape May

We may earn a commission if you buy through this link. It never changes what we write. Read our affiliate disclosure

Sponsored

Want the spooky side of Cape May?

The name has its story above. For the ghost stories, US Ghost Adventures runs walking ghost tours in Cape May.

See ghost tours in Cape May

We may earn a commission if you book through this link. It never changes what we write. Read our affiliate disclosure

Historical Sources & References

Spot something wrong, or know more? Tell us here. You can also or use our contact page. Corrections are noted here with their date, never made silently.

More name stories

State of New Jersey

New Jersey: Its Name Came From Sir George Carteret's Island

In 1664, a grant from the Duke of York said the land between the Hudson and the Delaware would "hereafter" be called "Nova-Cesaria or New-Jersey."

Documented
Atlantic County, NJ

Who Named Atlantic City, NJ? A Surveyor's Map, January 1853

Ocean City, Sea Beach, Surfing, Strand and Bath were all suggested for the resort that became Atlantic City, and its directors couldn't agree on any.

Documented
Bay, MD, VA

Chesapeake Bay Got Its Name Secondhand, From a Village

Chesapeake Bay got its name secondhand, from a village: in 1612, John Smith wrote that the bay was named for the home of the Chesapeake people.

Disputed
Camden County, NJ

Camden, New Jersey: How Cooper's Ferries Got a Lord's Name

Camden, New Jersey, was laid out in 1773 with a King Street and a Queen Street, yet named for Lord Camden, the British peer who opposed the king's policy.

Documented
Valley, VA, WV

Shenandoah Valley: 20 Spellings and No Sure Meaning

The Shenandoah Valley takes its name from a river that early records spelled at least 20 ways, from Gerundo to Zynodoa, and nobody knows what it meant.

Unknown
Mercer County, NJ

Trenton, New Jersey: The Trader Behind "Trent's-town"

New Jersey's capital was first written "Trent's-town," after William Trent, a Philadelphia trader who bought the land on the Delaware in 1714.

Documented
FeaturedSussex County, DE

Lewes, Delaware: A Name on a 1672 Deed, Before Penn

Lewes, Delaware, got William Penn's official sanction as the town's name in 1682, but the name already shows up on a 1672 land grant at the Horekill.

Disputed
Monmouth County, NJ

Why Is Freehold, NJ Called Freehold? A Land-Law Word

The name of Freehold, New Jersey, is an English land-law word, and it belonged to a whole township in 1693, long before the courthouse village took it.

Documented
Poster Master's illustrated pictorial map of New Jersey
SponsoredPoster · Poster Master

New Jersey pictorial map poster

An old illustrated map of New Jersey, sold as a poster by Poster Master.

We may earn a commission if you buy through this link.