Search

Why Is It Called Provincetown, MA? It Was Almost Herringtown

Provincetown is named for the Province Lands, the land at the tip of Cape Cod owned by the Province of Massachusetts Bay. A 1727 act made 'all the lands on the said Cape, being province lands' into 'a township by the name of Provincetown.' The settlers had asked for Herringtown, but an 1890 county history says lawmakers didn't like it.

Detail of an 1887 U.S. Geological Survey map showing the town of Provincetown strung along the curve of Provincetown Harbor, part of the label Province Lands across the dunes behind it, a railroad line, Town Hill, Mount Ararat and several ponds, including Great Pond and Shank Painter Pond.
Provincetown and the Province Lands on the U.S. Geological Survey's Provincetown sheet, 1887. U.S. Geological Survey, Provincetown sheet (1:62,500), 1887. Public domain. Cropped for display.

The name that didn’t pass

When the fishing settlement at the tip of Cape Cod asked to become a town in 1727, it picked Herringtown, and the lawmakers in Boston made it Provincetown. James H. Hopkins, who wrote the Provincetown chapter of the 1890 History of Barnstable County, tells it in two sentences: the inhabitants petitioned the General Court to make their precinct a separate town, and “the name selected—Herringtown, found little favor with the general court.”

What the court passed instead is still in print. The act’s title reads “An Act for erecting the precinct of Cape Cod into a township by the name of Provincetown.” Hopkins says it was passed July 14, 1727. The state’s own 1869 edition of the province laws prints a different note at the bottom: “Passed June 14; published July 11.” Either way, it was the summer of 1727, and either way it wasn’t Herringtown.

Land that belonged to the province

The new name wasn’t random. It came straight from the land itself. The act opens with “the province lands of Cape Cod” and then makes “all the lands on the said Cape, being province lands,” into “a township by the name of Provincetown.”

Hopkins explains how the land got that label. The Plymouth colony had held the tip of the Cape, and when the Province of Massachusetts Bay took over the colony’s rights in 1692, the land became province property. Since then, he writes, it had been “known as the ‘Province Lands.’” Before 1714 those lands seem to have been treated as part of Truro, Hopkins says. That year the General Court made them a precinct, “The Precinct of Cape Cod.”

There was a catch in the 1727 act. The town got a name, but not the land under it: the act saved “the right and title of this province to the said lands, which is to be in no wise prejudiced.” The Town of Provincetown’s own page on its old shoreline says the 1727 charter “did not provide the new town with authority to grant land to its settlers.” It also says the part of town east of Howland Street used to be Truro, while the part to the west “was known as the Province Lands.” You can see part of that label printed across the dunes on the 1887 map at the top of this page.

The tax story

You’ll sometimes read a different reason. Henry Gannett, who collected name origins for the U.S. Geological Survey in 1905, says Provincetown was “incorporated as the Province Town, because the inhabitants were exempt from taxation.” Gannett doesn’t give a source, and the act doesn’t say anything about taxes. What it does say is that the land was the province’s, and the town was named for it.

Before it was anything

Long before the precinct, the harbor had its moment. Hopkins writes that the Mayflower was “about to anchor in the harbor of Provincetown” on November 11, 1620, when the passengers signed their compact, weeks before they settled at Plymouth.

The Cape itself nearly had another name, too. John Smith’s 1616 Description of New England includes a table of names changed by Prince Charles, and on it Cape Cod becomes “Cape James.” That’s the same table that turned the harbor called Accomack into Plimouth. Plymouth kept the prince’s name. Cape Cod didn’t.

Quick answers

Why is Provincetown called Provincetown?

Because the town was made out of the Province Lands, land that belonged to the Province of Massachusetts Bay. The 1727 act that created it says so in nearly those words.

What did Provincetown want to be called?

Herringtown. The settlers chose it in their 1727 petition, but it “found little favor with the general court,” according to the 1890 county history.

Was Provincetown part of Truro?

Partly. Hopkins says the Province Lands seem to have been treated as part of Truro before 1714, and the town says the area east of Howland Street was once Truro.

Key dates

  1. 1616John Smith's schedule of new names lists Cape Cod as renamed Cape James. The new name doesn't stick.
  2. 1620November 11: the Mayflower anchors in the harbor of today's Provincetown, and the passengers sign their compact.
  3. 1692The Province of Massachusetts Bay takes over the Plymouth colony's rights, and the land becomes the Province Lands.
  4. 1714The General Court makes the Province Lands a precinct, the Precinct of Cape Cod.
  5. 1727The precinct asks to become a town called Herringtown. The General Court makes it Provincetown instead.
  6. 1905Henry Gannett's guide says the name came from the inhabitants being exempt from taxation, with no source.
A narrow street crowded with people walking past shingled and painted wooden shops, with strings of American flags hung across the street overhead, a rainbow flag on one storefront and a dark car in the street among the crowd.
Commercial Street in Provincetown, July 2023. Photo: David, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons (cropped).

Getting there

Open Provincetown in Google Maps

Opens in a new tab. The pin is the center of Provincetown in the USGS place-name record.

The closest airports, Amtrak stations and intercity bus stops, measured in a straight line from the center of Provincetown.

Airports

  • Cape Cod Gateway (HYA) Hyannis 27 mi 44 km
  • General Edward Lawrence Logan International (BOS) Boston 47 mi 76 km

Amtrak trains

Intercity buses

  • Peter Pan (BZ) Peter Pan Bus Lines · Provincetown under 1 mi 1 km
  • OurBus Quincy, MA (Quincy Center Station MBTA Bus Stop (bus shelter on Burgin Parkway between Saville & Dimmock St.) bus will not load at the station, follow signs to Burgin Parkway bus stop.) 44 mi 72 km
  • CandJ Bus Lines Logan International Airport (Terminal B2) 48 mi 77 km

Distances are as the crow flies, not by road. We don't list schedules or fares because they change; check with the airline, Amtrak or the bus company before you go. Official data (FAA commercial service airports (2025), FAA airport locations, Amtrak stations and Intercity Bus Atlas) from the FAA and the U.S. Bureau of Transportation Statistics, checked Nov 13, 2026.

Sponsored

Staying in Provincetown?

Compare hotels in Provincetown, Massachusetts, on Expedia.

See hotels in Provincetown

We may earn a commission if you buy through this link. It never changes what we write. Read our affiliate disclosure

Sponsored

Want the spooky side of Provincetown?

The name has its story above. For the ghost stories, US Ghost Adventures runs walking ghost tours in Provincetown.

See ghost tours in Provincetown

We may earn a commission if you book through this link. It never changes what we write. Read our affiliate disclosure

Historical Sources & References

Spot something wrong, or know more? Tell us here. You can also or use our contact page. Corrections are noted here with their date, never made silently.

More name stories

State of Massachusetts

Massachusetts' Name: The "Great Hills" of Milton and Quincy

Massachusetts means a place "at, or near, the great hills," and Roger Williams was told the hills were the Blue Hills, in what's now Milton and Quincy.

Documented
Plymouth County, MA

Why Is Plymouth, MA, Called Plymouth? A Prince Picked It

Plymouth, Massachusetts, had its English name four years before the Mayflower showed up, and the man who chose it was a prince in England.

Documented
Island and National Park, ME

Acadia, Maine: Greek Paradise or Mi'kmaq Word?

Acadia National Park carries the name of an old French colony, and nobody has settled whether that name began as a Greek paradise or a Mi'kmaq word.

Disputed
Norfolk County, MA

Quincy, Massachusetts and John Quincy Adams Share a Namesake

Quincy, Massachusetts, and John Quincy Adams were named for the same man, Col. John Quincy, who lay dying when the future president was born.

Documented
Bay, MD, VA

Chesapeake Bay Got Its Name Secondhand, From a Village

Chesapeake Bay got its name secondhand, from a village: in 1612, John Smith wrote that the bay was named for the home of the Chesapeake people.

Disputed
Essex County, MA

Gloucester, Massachusetts: Named by Settlers or for a Duke?

Gloucester, Massachusetts, got its English name at a colonial court in 1642, and why is still debated: the settlers' hometown or a new Duke of Gloucester.

Disputed
FeaturedMiddlesex County, MA

Lowell or Derby? How Lowell, Massachusetts, Got Its Name

Lowell, Massachusetts, came down to two names, Lowell or Derby, and Nathan Appleton, who was there, says it took him five words to settle it.

Documented
Essex County, MA

Rockport, Massachusetts: Rocky Shores and Granite Quarries

When Rockport, Massachusetts, split from Gloucester in 1840, it took a name an 1847 gazetteer called appropriate and tied to the character of its shores.

Documented
Poster Master's illustrated pictorial map of Massachusetts
SponsoredPoster · Poster Master

Massachusetts pictorial map poster

An old illustrated map of Massachusetts, sold as a poster by Poster Master.

We may earn a commission if you buy through this link.