Search

Nags Head, North Carolina: A Lantern Legend, No Known Origin

Nobody knows. The National Register nomination for the town's old beach cottages says the origin 'remains unknown' and lists three ideas: the shape of the island, places with the same name in England, and a light tied to a nag's head to lure boats ashore. The North Carolina Gazetteer says the name is on maps as early as 1738.

Detail of the Army's Roanoke Island quadrangle, printed in 1943, with the name Nags Head beside a line of buildings along U.S. 158 on a narrow strip of land between the Atlantic and Roanoke Sound, the letters PO, a mark labeled Nags Head CG, the words Jackey Ridge over sand and green patches, Buzzard Bay and Manns Point to the north, Baum Point across the water to the southwest, and the letters ATLANT and ROANO in large type.
Nags Head on the War Department's Roanoke Island quadrangle, printed in 1943. War Department, Corps of Engineers, U.S. Army, Roanoke Island quadrangle, North Carolina (1:125,000), compiled in 1942 from Air Corps photographs and printed in 1943 at Fort Belvoir, Virginia. Public domain. Cropped for display.

Nags Head, North Carolina, has a name nobody can explain, and one of its most popular stories, a lantern hung on a horse to lure ships ashore, is a legend. It’s a good legend, and you’ll find it in the reference books. But each of them is careful to call it a story, and none of them knows where the name really came from.

The lantern on the nag

The North Carolina Gazetteer, edited by William S. Powell and Michael Hill, starts by admitting the problem: “Numerous legends exist explaining the origin of the name.” Then it tells the favorite:

“One of the most popular tells of natives who tied lanterns around the necks of ponies (‘nags’), which were driven up and down the beach at night. The motion of the lanterns resembled that of a vessel at anchor and lured ships at sea into the shore, where they were wrecked and easily robbed.”

The town’s own land use plan of 1976 tells it too, quoting Bill Sharpe’s A New Geography of North Carolina from 1954:

“Residents of the coast once stripped wrecked vessels of their cargo, and some say Bankers even tried to lure ships to their doom. This accomplished by hanging a lighted lantern, around the neck of a horse and leading the nag along the beach, the bobbing light persuading mariners offshore to believe it came from a boat riding at safe anchorage…”

Note the “some say.” The plan goes on, noting that Sharpe himself later raised a doubt: “there is some doubt as to the credibility of this story, yet, no one seems to know the true origin of the name ‘Nags Head.’” No source here names a ship that was lost this way, and this page won’t invent one.

A legend that sticks to a town name isn’t unique to the Outer Banks. In Belfast, Maine, an old local tradition says the name was settled with a penny toss.

The shape of the island, or a name from England

The National Register nomination for the Nags Head Beach Cottage Row Historic District, written by Catherine W. Cockshutt of the state’s Division of Archives and History, puts the lantern story beside two others and doesn’t pick one:

“The origin of the name Nags Head remains unknown: some claim it comes from the shape of the island, others cite as source places of the same name in England, and still others assert that it came from early settlers’ habit of tying a light to a nag’s head, who walked the beach at night to lure boats to their doom and thus enrich salvagers.”

The Gazetteer adds that “Nags Head as a place name appears in various parts of England, the Channel Islands, and the West Indies,” but it doesn’t say this one came from any of them. York, Nebraska, has a similar puzzle on a bigger scale: several Yorks have been proposed for it, and none has been proven.

On the maps by 1738

The name is old. The Gazetteer says it “appears on maps of the area as early as 1738,” without naming the map. That’s the same year the Gazetteer gives for Chickehauk, the early form of Kitty Hawk, farther up the Outer Banks. Both names were on paper long before anyone built a summer cottage here.

A summer resort since the 1830s

The Gazetteer calls Nags Head “a popular summer resort since the 1830s.” The nomination tells how that began, and it flags the story as tradition: “Tradition claims that in about 1830, Francis Nixon, a wealthy Perquimans County planter, explored the area” for a place to escape the summer fevers of the mainland. “He is said to have bought 200 acres, paying fifty cents an acre.” That’s about 81 hectares.

By 1838 a large hotel, “said to accommodate 200 guests,” stood on the sound side, the nomination says. Before the Civil War, the resort filled mostly with planters and merchants from the Albemarle and the other northeastern counties of North Carolina. Confederate troops used the hotel as a command post and set fire to it in 1862 as they retreated from Roanoke Island. After the war, families started building along the ocean, and some moved their cottages across the sand on rollers.

A lifesaving station opened at Nags Head in 1874, the Gazetteer says. The town was incorporated in 1923, lost its charter in 1949, and was incorporated again in 1961.

A restricted Army map of 1943

The map at the top of this page comes from the Roanoke Island quadrangle, which the 649th Engineers compiled for the War Department in 1942 from Air Corps photographs. This copy was printed in 1943 at Fort Belvoir, Virginia, and stamped “RESTRICTED,” a marking cancelled in 1946. It shows Nags Head as a row of buildings on U.S. 158, with a post office and the Nags Head Coast Guard station. North of the post office, you’ll see the label “Jackey Ridge,” spelled just that way.

Quick answers

Where does the name Nags Head come from?

Nobody knows. The National Register nomination for the town’s historic beach cottages says the origin “remains unknown” and lists three ideas: the shape of the island, places of the same name in England, and a light tied to a nag’s head.

Is the lantern-and-horse story true?

No source proves it. The North Carolina Gazetteer calls it one of numerous legends, and the town’s 1976 land use plan, passing along Bill Sharpe’s own later doubt, says there is “some doubt as to the credibility of this story.”

How old is the name Nags Head?

The North Carolina Gazetteer says the name appears on maps of the area as early as 1738.

Key dates

  1. 1738The name Nags Head appears on maps of the area, according to The North Carolina Gazetteer.
  2. 1830About this time, tradition says, Francis Nixon, a Perquimans County planter, explores the area for a summer home.
  3. 1838A hotel said to hold 200 guests stands on the sound side.
  4. 1862Confederate troops retreating from Roanoke Island set fire to the hotel.
  5. 1874The Nags Head lifesaving station is established, later a Coast Guard station.
  6. 1923Nags Head is incorporated. The charter is repealed in 1949.
  7. 1943The Army prints the Roanoke Island quadrangle, marked restricted, showing Nags Head.
  8. 1961Nags Head is incorporated again.
  9. 1976The town's land use plan says no one seems to know the true origin of the name.
Nags Head, North Carolina, seen from a height, with a row of weathered brown wooden cottages in front, rows of tall pastel beach houses behind them, utility poles, sand and dune fencing in the foreground, and a strip of ocean on the left horizon.
Beach houses at Nags Head, May 2012. Photo: lns1122, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons (cropped).

Things to do in Nags Head, North Carolina

  • Jockey's Ridge State Park

    Home to the tallest living sand dune system on the Atlantic coast, with hang gliding lessons from a private concessionaire, a sound-side area on Roanoke Sound for swimming and paddling, and the eastern end of the Mountains-to-Sea State Trail.

  • Jennette's Pier

    An ocean fishing pier in Nags Head run by the North Carolina Aquariums, for anglers of all skill levels, with a pier house and full ADA access.

  • Nags Head Woods Preserve

    One of the largest remaining maritime forests on the East Coast, The Nature Conservancy says, with 8 trails from 0.2 to 3 miles (0.3 to 4.8 km) long through wooded dunes, ponds and brackish marsh.

  • Bodie Island Light Station

    The lighthouse at the northern end of Cape Hatteras National Seashore, the third built for this stretch of coast, which first showed its light through a first-order Fresnel lens on October 1, 1872.

Getting there

Open Nags Head in Google Maps

Opens in a new tab. The pin is the center of Nags Head in the USGS place-name record.

The closest airports, Amtrak stations and intercity bus stops, measured in a straight line from the center of Nags Head.

Airports

Amtrak trains

Intercity buses

  • Greyhound Elizabeth City Edgewood Dr 39 mi 63 km

Distances are as the crow flies, not by road. We don't list schedules or fares because they change; check with the airline, Amtrak or the bus company before you go. Official data (FAA commercial service airports (2025), FAA airport locations, Amtrak stations and Intercity Bus Atlas) from the FAA and the U.S. Bureau of Transportation Statistics, checked Nov 17, 2026.

Sponsored

Staying in Nags Head?

Compare hotels in Nags Head, North Carolina, on Expedia.

See hotels in Nags Head

We may earn a commission if you buy through this link. It never changes what we write. Read our affiliate disclosure

Historical Sources & References

Spot something wrong, or know more? Tell us here. You can also or use our contact page. Corrections are noted here with their date, never made silently.

More name stories

State of North Carolina

North Carolina's Name and the Lost Province of Carolana

Before there was a North Carolina, there was Carolana, a province King Charles I granted in 1630 to his attorney general, Sir Robert Heath.

Disputed
Dare County, NC

Kitty Hawk, North Carolina: Chickehauk Before the Wrights

Kitty Hawk, North Carolina, was on maps as Chickehauk by 1738, more than 160 years before the Wright brothers' first powered flights nearby in 1903.

Unknown
Bay, MD, VA

Chesapeake Bay Got Its Name Secondhand, From a Village

Chesapeake Bay got its name secondhand, from a village: in 1612, John Smith wrote that the bay was named for the home of the Chesapeake people.

Disputed
Pasquotank County, NC

Elizabeth City, North Carolina: Which Elizabeth Was It?

Elizabeth City, North Carolina, may be named for Elizabeth Tooley, whose plantation became the town and who ran a grog shop there, or for a queen.

Disputed
Valley, VA, WV

Shenandoah Valley: 20 Spellings and No Sure Meaning

The Shenandoah Valley takes its name from a river that early records spelled at least 20 ways, from Gerundo to Zynodoa, and nobody knows what it meant.

Unknown
Craven County, NC

New Bern, North Carolina: A River Plus a Swiss City

New Bern, North Carolina, wasn't simply a new Bern: its Swiss founder wrote that he joined the river's name, which he spelled Neuws, to the name of Bern.

Documented
FeaturedWake County, NC

Cary, North Carolina: Named for a Temperance Orator

Frank Page settled by the railroad west of Raleigh around 1854, and the town that grew there, Cary, North Carolina, honors an Ohio temperance orator.

Documented
Wayne County, NC

Goldsboro, North Carolina: A Junction Named for Its Engineer

Goldsboro, North Carolina, began as a railroad depot at a crossroads, and the man who housed the railroad's engineer claimed he named it for him.

Documented
Poster Master's illustrated pictorial map of North Carolina
SponsoredPoster · Poster Master

North Carolina pictorial map poster

An old illustrated map of North Carolina, sold as a poster by Poster Master.

We may earn a commission if you buy through this link.