Search

Why Is It Called Stillwater, Minnesota? Calm Water and Maine

John McKusick proposed the name Stillwater in 1843, when he and three partners formed the Stillwater Lumber Company to build a sawmill near the head of Lake St. Croix. An 1881 county history gives three reasons: the stillness of the lake, the oddity of a mill beside still water, and fond memories of Stillwater, Maine.

Detail of a 1951 U.S. Geological Survey map showing the Stillwater street grid in pink with City Hall, schools and a hospital labeled, Lake McKusick and Lily Lake on the left, and a bridge crossing the St. Croix River to Wisconsin, with the state boundary dashed in the river.
Stillwater, Lake McKusick and the St. Croix on the U.S. Geological Survey's Stillwater sheet, 1951. U.S. Geological Survey, Stillwater sheet (1:24,000), 1951. Public domain. Cropped for display.

A name picked for a sawmill

John McKusick named Stillwater in 1843 for the calm water of Lake St. Croix, the oddity of a sawmill on still water, and memories of Stillwater, Maine. When he suggested it, nobody was planning a town at all, just a mill.

The story comes from Edward D. Neill’s History of Washington County and the St. Croix Valley, published in 1881, while McKusick was still alive. Neill says McKusick had left Cornish, Maine, and that a man named Jacob Fisher had found a good mill site on the St. Croix but couldn’t build on it himself. McKusick went down to St. Louis, met his partners Elias McKean and Calvin F. Leach, bought the outfit for a sawmill, and brought it up the Mississippi by steamboat. The party landed “at the site of Stillwater, October 11th, 1843.” They agreed to pay Fisher $300 for his claim and hire him as millwright.

Then, Neill writes, came the part you’re here for:

“Then came the question of a name; ‘What shall we call the place?’ All proposed a name, but the name of Stillwater, proposed by John McKusick, was adopted. This name was suggested by the stillness of the water in the lake, the anomaly of building a mill beside still water, and by fond recollections of Stillwater, Maine.”

That’s three reasons packed into one sentence. Neill calls the second one an “anomaly,” and a page earlier he shows how they meant to get around it: on the bluff, the men agreed that “Brown’s creek could be turned into the lake above,” with a canal to carry the water down to the mill site.

The company came first

Neill also copied the agreement the partners signed on October 26, 1843. There was no lawyer in the group, he says, so they dictated it to one of the workers, and it was copied later. Neill calls it the first articles of agreement made on ground that, by the time he wrote, lay inside Stillwater’s city limits, and the name is right there in the first article:

“Article first. It is understood by this agreement, that the heretofore named individuals form themselves into a company to continue and exist by the name of the Stillwater Lumber Company.”

The partners were John McKusick, Elias McKean, Elam Greeley and Calvin F. Leach, and the company’s purpose was “building a saw-mill near the head of Lake St. Croix, Wisconsin territory.” So on paper, the mill was going up in Wisconsin Territory.

That helps explain why Henry Gannett’s 1905 federal bulletin on place names tells it a little differently. Gannett says Stillwater was “named for a lumber company which selected this site for its mill.” He isn’t wrong, exactly: the company carried the name before any town did. But Neill’s account, written closer to the people involved, says where the company’s name came from in the first place. Warren Upham’s 1920 place-name dictionary follows Neill and dates the adoption of McKusick’s name to October 26, the same day as the agreement.

Maine, but not his hometown

Some retellings make Stillwater, Maine, McKusick’s hometown. Upham says McKusick was born in Cornish, Maine, on December 18, 1815. Stillwater, Maine, is a different place, and Neill only speaks of “fond recollections” of it. Neither book explains what tied McKusick to it, so it’s best left as a fond memory, not a birthplace.

McKusick stayed. Upham says he came to Minnesota in 1840, built the county’s first sawmill, served as a state senator from 1863 to 1866, and died in Stillwater on October 26, 1900, exactly 57 years after the name was adopted. Lake McKusick, which you can spot at the upper left of the 1951 map, is named for him.

He wasn’t the last Maine lumberman to come through. Upham says the Staples family arrived in Stillwater from Topsham, Maine, in 1853-54, and their logging and manufacturing interests later gave their name to Staples in Todd County.

Names before Stillwater

The site wasn’t empty of names before 1843. Upham says that between 1838 and 1841 Joseph R. Brown platted a townsite called Dahkotah on what’s now the north part of the city. And Neill, writing about the river rather than the town, says the St. Croix and Lake St. Croix were “always called by the Sioux, Hogan-wahnkay-kin, (the place where the fish lies.)” That’s his spelling and his translation, and it belongs to the water, not to the settlement.

The mill site grew into a town anyway. Upham says Stillwater was incorporated as a city on March 4, 1854, the same day as St. Paul.

Quick answers

Who named Stillwater, Minnesota?

John McKusick, a lumberman from Maine. Neill’s 1881 county history says that when the partners asked “What shall we call the place?” his proposal, Stillwater, was adopted.

Is Stillwater named after Stillwater, Maine?

Partly. Neill lists “fond recollections of Stillwater, Maine” as one of three reasons, next to the stillness of the lake and the oddity of a mill beside still water.

Was Stillwater named for a lumber company?

In a way. Gannett’s 1905 bulletin says so, and the Stillwater Lumber Company agreement is dated October 26, 1843. Neill and Upham say McKusick proposed the name, and Upham dates its adoption to that same day.

Key dates

  1. 1843October 11: John McKusick's party lands at the site with the outfit for a sawmill, per Neill's 1881 county history.
  2. 1843October 26: the Stillwater Lumber Company agreement is signed. Upham dates the adoption of McKusick's name Stillwater to the same day.
  3. 1854March 4: Stillwater is incorporated as a city, the same date as St. Paul, according to Upham.
  4. 1900October 26: John McKusick dies in Stillwater, 57 years to the day after the name was adopted.
A gray steel lift bridge with its middle span raised between two towers over calm blue water, with brick buildings and green bluffs behind it under a clear sky.
The Stillwater lift bridge with its span raised over the St. Croix, July 2013. Photo: jkmarko, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons (cropped).

Getting there

Open Stillwater in Google Maps

Opens in a new tab. The pin is the center of Stillwater in the USGS place-name record.

The closest airports, Amtrak stations and intercity bus stops, measured in a straight line from the center of Stillwater.

Airports

Intercity buses

  • FlixBus Hudson Wi 8 mi 12 km
  • Jefferson Lines St. Paul (Union Depot) 16 mi 25 km
  • Land to Air Express St. Paul (Union Depot) 16 mi 25 km

Distances are as the crow flies, not by road. We don't list schedules or fares because they change; check with the airline, Amtrak or the bus company before you go. Official data (FAA commercial service airports (2025), FAA airport locations, Amtrak stations and Intercity Bus Atlas) from the FAA and the U.S. Bureau of Transportation Statistics, checked Nov 13, 2026.

Sponsored

Staying in Stillwater?

Compare hotels in Stillwater, Minnesota, on Expedia.

See hotels in Stillwater

We may earn a commission if you buy through this link. It never changes what we write. Read our affiliate disclosure

Sponsored

Want the spooky side of Stillwater?

The name has its story above. For the ghost stories, US Ghost Adventures runs walking ghost tours in Stillwater.

See ghost tours in Stillwater

We may earn a commission if you book through this link. It never changes what we write. Read our affiliate disclosure

Historical Sources & References

Spot something wrong, or know more? Tell us here. You can also or use our contact page. Corrections are noted here with their date, never made silently.

More name stories

State of Minnesota

Minnesota: How It Got Its Name (Picture Milk in Water)

If you want to see what Minnesota means, drop a little milk into some water: that's how Dakota women explained the word to Mrs. Moses N. Adams.

Documented
Ramsey County, MN

Saint Paul, Minnesota: The Capital That Started as Pig's Eye

Before Saint Paul, Minnesota, had a saint's name, the place was called Pig's Eye, after a one-eyed whiskey seller named Pierre Parrant.

Documented
Peak, SD

Black Elk Peak Was Harney Peak Until 2016

South Dakota's highest point was Harney Peak, after an Army general, until 2016, when a federal board renamed it for the Lakota holy man Black Elk.

Documented
Hennepin County, MN

Who Named Minneapolis, Minnesota? Two Friends, a Greek Word

Nobody argues about what Minneapolis, Minnesota, means: it's a Dakota word for water stuck onto the Greek word for city.

Documented
River valley and National Park, OH

Cuyahoga Valley: A River So Crooked It Named a Town

In Ohio's Cuyahoga Valley, the river loops back to within about 50 feet (15 m) of itself at Peninsula, and that bend gave the village its name.

Disputed
Goodhue County, MN

Red Wing, Minnesota: A Name Passed Down by Dakota Chiefs

Red Wing, Minnesota, carries a name that wasn't one man's: a historian of the Sioux counted at least four Dakota chiefs in a row who bore it.

Documented
FeaturedBlue Earth County, MN

Mankato, Minnesota: Blue Earth and a Water-Spirit Mix-Up

According to a 1909 county history, the man who suggested the name Mankato, Minnesota, in 1852 thought it belonged to a water spirit in a German tale.

Documented
Stearns County, MN

St. Cloud, Minnesota: A Name Borrowed From a Napoleon Book

St. Cloud, Minnesota, got its name because the man who platted it had been reading a life of Napoleon.

Documented
Poster Master's illustrated pictorial map of Minnesota
SponsoredPoster · Poster Master

Minnesota pictorial map poster

An old illustrated map of Minnesota, sold as a poster by Poster Master.

We may earn a commission if you buy through this link.